The main difference in between spontaneous generation and biogenesis is that the spontaneous generation is a theory that describes the beginning of life indigenous non-living things whereas the biogenesis is a theory that describes the origination of life indigenous pre-existing forms of life. Furthermore, voluntarily generation or abiogenesis has not been verified by clinical experiments when biogenesis has been proven by clinical experiments.

You are watching: What is the difference between spontaneous generation and biogenesis

Spontaneous generation and biogenesis are two hypotheses that explain the beginning of life. Because of the scientific background the biogenesis, it is the many widely accepted phenomenon for the origination of life.

Key locations Covered

1. What is voluntarily Generation – Definition, Hypotheses, Evidence 2. What is Biogenesis – Definition, clinical Experiments 3. What room the Similarities in between Spontaneous Generation and also Biogenesis – summary of usual Features 4. What is the Difference between Spontaneous Generation and also Biogenesis – comparison of vital Differences

Key Terms

Aristotelian Abiogenesis, Biogenesis, beginning of Life, Pasteur’s Experiment, Spallanzani’s Experiment, voluntarily Generation


What is voluntary Generation

Spontaneous generation is one of the theories developed to explain the origin of life. It claims that life source from not natural or meaningless materials. Spontaneous generation is also called Aristotelian abiogenesis because of its ancient Greek proponent. The id of spontaneous generation very first evolved as result of the invisibility and stealth of some organisms such together mice, flies, and bacteria. In 1668, Francesco Redi hypothesized macroscopic voluntarily generation through the observation of the growth of maggots in rotting meat. But, through the creation of the microscopic lense in the 18th century, this credibility to be eroded due to the fact that people might see paris eggs as well as bacteria through microscopes.


Figure 1: suspect Fossilized Microorganisms discovered in Hydrothermal Vent, The Earliest recognized Life-Forms ~ above Earth

It is thought about that the planet was developed 4.54 million years ago. The earliest, undisputed evidence of life on earth are microbial mat fossils uncovered from a 3.48 million years old sandstone in western Australia. Some researches state that the origination of life on planet started even before 4.25 million years.


Figure 2: Stromatolites, Pre-Cambrian Petrified Biofilm in Lacier national Park, Montana

With the presumption that the life spontaneously source on earth, Miller–Urey experiment and comparable experiments check to show the development of basic chemicals of life such together amino mountain in comparable conditions come the early on earth. Lightning and also radiation detailed energy because that these chemical reactions. An additional hypothesis, the ‘metabolism first’ hypothesis, concentrates on the catalysis of chemical reactions, i beg your pardon are considered to provide the precursor molecules required by self-replication.

What is Biogenesis

Biogenesis is another hypothesis that explains the origin of life ~ above earth, stating the life develops produce brand-new life forms. Lazzaro Spallanzani to be the first person to disprove spontaneous generation. In 1767, he confirmed that microorganisms can be killed by boiling. He boiled meat in a sealed container and this broth walk not show bacterial expansion subsequently. In 1864, luigi Pasteur disproved the voluntary generation through a series of experiments similar to that of Spallanzani. He demonstrated the life does no arise in areas that have actually not been contaminated by present life. Pasteur’s experiment is described below.


Figure 3: Pasteur’s Experiment

Biogenesis is the widely welcomed hypothesis for the beginning of life because it can always be showed by scientific experiments.

Similarities in between Spontaneous Generation and Biogenesis

Abiogenesis and biogenesis are two hypotheses that try to define the origin of life ~ above earth.

Difference between Spontaneous Generation and Biogenesis


Abiogenesis refers to the an alleged production of living organisms from non-living matter, together inferred native the noticeable appearance that life in part supposedly sterile environments. Biogenesis refers to the theory that living issue arises only from various other living matter. This indicates the difference between spontaneous generation and abiogenesis.

Proposed by

Some the the proponents of spontaneous generation to be Francesco Redi, Alexander Oparin, Stanley Miller, and also Harold Urey while some of the advocates of biogenesis were wilhelm Harvey, Theodore Schwann, Lazzaro Spallanzani, man Needham, and Louis Pasteur.


Spontaneous generation says that life on planet has source from non-living compounds if biogenesis says that life on planet originated indigenous the pre-existing life forms.

Scientific Evidence

Spontaneous generation has not been scientifically verified while biogenesis has been showed by clinical experiments.

Based on

Spontaneous generation is based on observations and also rational think while biogenesis is based on practical experiments and also material evidence. This one more important difference between spontaneous generation and also abiogenesis.

See more: What Are The Rules Of The Death Note : Every Rule In The Manga


Spontaneous generation states that life on earth originated from non-living things while biogenesis says that life on earth originated indigenous pre-existing life things. This is the main difference between spontaneous generation and also abiogenesis.


1. “Theory the Abiogenesis.” The facility for Planetary Science, Available Here2. Dohrman, Paul. “The concept of Biogenesis.” Sciencing, 25 Apr. 2018, Available Here

Image Courtesy:

1. “Champagne vent white smokers” by NOAA – (Public Domain) via Commons Wikimedia 2. “Stromatolites” through P. Carrara, NPS – national Park business – (Public Domain) via Commons Wikimedia3. “Pasteur’s experiment experimentation spontaneous generation and biogenesis” through Thebiologyprimer – Own work-related (CC BY-SA 4.0) via Commons Wikimedia