Abolition and Antebellum Reform

*
When the Boston abolitionist thomas Wentworth Higginson looked ago on the years before the polite War, that wrote, “there dominated then a phrase, ‘the Sisterhood the Reforms.’” He had in mental “a range of social and also psychological theories of which one was intended to expropriate all, if any.” Of the sisterhood, anti-slavery was standing out as the best-remembered and also most hotly debated, also though it was no the largest in terms of membership or the most enduring. (That honor goes to the temperance movement.) Abolitionism continues to fascinate because of its ar in the sectional problem leading to the civil War, its attack on gender and racial inequality, and also its foreshadowing the the twentieth-century Civil rights Movement.

You are watching: How did the abolitionist movement that arose in the 1830s differ from earlier antislavery efforts

Sometimes, however, the is valuable to think about abolitionism in relation to Higginson’s Sisterhood the Reforms. The years in between 1815—the year that significant the finish of the battle of 1812—and 1861 walk indeed create a exceptional flowering that movements devoted to improving society, morals, and also individuals. Some aramuseum.orgpear silly indigenous a contemporary perspective (would chearamuseum.org postage really foster global unity and also understanding?), but many contemporaries nonetheless took castle seriously. And also although Higginson exaggerated connections in between movements, it was reasonably common for civilization who believed in anti-slavery reform also to think in spiritual reforms, women’s rights, temperance, and also health reform. (The last was based on the idea that suitable diet—a severely vegetarian one—could remove illness and produce moral human being beings.)

Placing anti-slavery in ~ the sisterhood helps united state to view both what was and what was not distinctive about it, and begin to resolve the bigger question the why certain periods in American history provide specifically fertile ground because that reform movements. The answer to the latter question is not constantly straightforward. Drunkenness did no begin about 1819, when a temperance movement started to take it sharamuseum.orge; slavery had actually not suddenly readjusted in 1831, the year a new, an ext radical anti-slavery movement emerged; and also the oppression of females did no start roughly 1848, the year that the pioneering women’s legal rights convention in Seneca Falls, brand-new York. For that matter, segregation and racial discrimination started well before the twentieth-century Civil rights Movement. Do it every the more difficult to answer the concern of timing is the reality that durations of intense reform task sometimes coincide with economic crises, as was significantly the case during the great Depression the the 1930s, if at various other times such together the steady Era (1890–1919) and also the 1960s, durations of revolutionary are also periods of general prosperity. Yet regardless of whether reform motions take place in good or poor economic times, the point is that reform activities usually are an ext than just simple, direct responses to a regarded problem.

Multiple transforms converged after the battle of 1812 to develop the Sisterhood of Reforms. Improvements in transportation—especially steamboats, canals, and also railroads—made it simpler to send lecturers and publications—including abolitionists, other reformers, and their writings—far and also wide. And brand-new printing technologies in the 1830s lower the cost of publications, consisting of publications native abolitionists.

At the exact same time, a dynamic American economy produced a new class the men and women v the recreation time and also financial sources to devote to reform movements. A comparison v eighteenth-century reformers is revealing. They to be fewer in number and, through some significant exceptions (mostly Quakers), had tendency to be part-timers favor Benjamin Franklin who were either retired or had actually other jobs. Through contrast, antebellum reformers were both much more numerous and, in instances like that of the abolitionist editor william Lloyd Garrison, had actually no other career.

Social and also economic change also noted a mental context for reform. ~ 1820, the raramuseum.orgid expansion of cities and expanding commerce and manufacturing aramuseum.orgpeared both come herald a glorious future and also to open the door come temptations and also vice. Exactly how to ensure the God, and also not Satan and Mammon, would certainly win?

Behind that inquiry lay two powerful traditions that compelled reversal to comparison what America and also Americans were through what they must be. One to be the legacy of the American Revolution. Also when most an important of their government, reversal evoked it. The very first women’s rights convention modeled that declaration after the explanation of Independence. Similarly, ~ publicly and also notoriously burn a copy that the structure on July 4, 1854, wilhelm Lloyd Garrison asked, “What is an abolitionist however a thank you very much believer in the declaration of ’76?” He was repudiating a federal government that sustained slavery, not the values of the Revolution.

The other tradition was evangelical Protestantism. One outpouring of spiritual fervor in the at an early stage nineteenth century—sometimes called the Second an excellent Awakening—swept from west to east and fired the mind of millions of Americans. The encouraged plenty of to think they had a moral imperative to carry out what they can to bring around the Kingdom of God top top earth. Although no all evangelicals were reformers, and also not every reformers to be evangelicals, the Awakening put the power of faith behind a id that separation, personal, instance men and also women could readjust the world, rather than passively expropriate as inevitable whatever fate hosted in store, together their ancestors regularly had done.

Why must they conclude that that job dropped to them fairly than to your leaders? The most famed foreign observer of the young republic, Alexis de Tocqueville, was struck through the peculiar propensity of americans to form local “voluntary associations” to achieve a wide selection of goals, consisting of reforms. In huge measure, this was a reasonable method in a country with couple of effective institutional resources of moral authority, and also one with reasonably weak political institutions, no national church, and also a culture mistrustful of governmental power. Usage of voluntary associations likewise reflected a feeling among some—especially the many radical abolitionists—that elected officials were component of the problem, no the solution. Antebellum reformers thought in ethical absolutes; politicians think in the arts of the deal, even when the result is compromise through an evil choose slavery. Under the circumstances, it seemed better to go roughly the political mechanism than v it (a position temperance reformers and also some abolitionists started to reconsider in the 1840s).

If multiple changes came together after the battle of 1812 to create the Sisterhood that Reforms, they walk not identify how antebellum reversal tried to change the people or what they pertained to as the key thing wrong through it. Also within a movement like abolitionism, there was widespread disagreement end tactics and goals.

Running through many reforms, however, were common themes and assumptions, one of the most crucial of which to be a passionately held belief that individuals must have the ability to act as totally free moral agents, qualified of selecting right from wrong, and not border by the “arbitrary power” the someone else (like a slaveholder or non ethical husband) or something else (like alcohol, bad diet, or mental illness). In the respect, abolitionism was the ultimate expression of the antebellum reform impulse: Slaves, because that abolitionists, to be the mirror image of freedom, icons of what it was not—the many extreme instance of unfreedom. This logic helps define the nearby connection between abolitionists and reforms such as the women’s rights movement, and why abolitionists felt an affinity through European revolutionaries and efforts to end serfdom in Russia. All such cases, in their view, were part of a larger worldwide drama of the development of freedom. With this an effective rhetorical tradition entrenched by the 1840s, the is no accident that the hatchet “slave” persisted in revolutionary rhetoric transparent the nineteenth century, lengthy after the school itself passed away in 1865—drunkards as “slaves” come the bottle, women as “slaves” come men, and also factory employees as “wage slaves.”

Abolitionists themselves to be vague around what freedom might mean in exercise after the death of slavery, and also unconcerned that others might disagree through their definitions. Even so, their focus on individual moral firm and their use of the antithesis in between slavery and also freedom to define freedom’s absence and presence locates them in ~ Higginson’s sisterhood. However in three important respects—in your views on their government, gender, and also race—abolitionists parted agency with other sisterhood reforms. Couple of reform movements prior to 1861 developed the an essential attacks top top the American political device that abolitionists placed in denouncing its devil’s bargain with slavery. And also although all significant antebellum revolutionary depended greatly upon women, only a handful of utopian communities gave as significant a voice come them as abolitionism in its many radical forms.

Most distinctive, however, was exactly how abolitionists framed the relationship between anti-slavery and also race, using ideas and also concepts the went well past the movement’s attack on slavery and also that eventually came residence in the kind of attacks on discriminatory laws and practices in the North. In addition, the abolitionist activity was unusually interracial. The reputation of a couple of black abolitionists—notably Frederick Douglass, Sojourner Truth, and also Harriet Tubman—somewhat obscures the high degree to i beg your pardon lesser-known afri American abolitionists likewise supported the reason in every way possible, consisting of with their own organizations, pens, speeches, and dollars. If racism never entirely disaramuseum.orgpeared amongst white abolitionists, and also if relations in between them and also black colleagues were occasionally strained, the is nonetheless true the no other activity of the day to be remotely close come abolitionism in interracial cooperation, in mobilizing black color communities, and also in daunting racism in both theory and practice. ~ above those issues, abolitionism was both component of a taramuseum.orge of sister reforms and also a motion that went well beyond them.

See more: How Many Tablespoon In 200 Grams Of Butter To Tablespoons Conversion

Ronald Walters, Professor of background at The man Hopkins University, is the writer of The Antislavery aramuseum.orgpeal: American Abolitionism after 1830 (1984)and editor that Primers for Prudery: sex-related Advice to victor America(1973)and A black Woman’s Odyssey v Russia and also Jamaica: The rigid of Nancy Prince(1989).