The actual Story Behind man Marston's Scars Is Dumb Red Dead Redemption 2 defines how the original hero, john Marston, obtained his scars - and the tale is much from the heroic story the was expected.

You are watching: How did john marston get his scars


Red Dead Redemption 2 overtime 100-hour week
Warning: This post contains minor spoiler for Red Dead Redemption 2.

Red Dead Redemption 2 reveals exactly how John Marston got his scars - and it"s a man story. The success that Red Dead Redemption is because of a lot of factors, yet the likability that Marston is chief among them. In Red Dead Redemption 2, man Marston is tho around. He plays a fairly significant, albeit unplayable, part in the prequel story, but John"s a different man, and not just due to the fact that he"s younger.

In Red Dead Redemption 2, John is among the many junior members of the Dutch van der Linde gang, and perhaps the most mocked. As soon as the brand-new protagonist Arthur Morgan very first refers to man in the game, it"s to call him a boring moron. Yet the most ridiculous facet of John is among his many intriguing attributes in the very first Red Dead Redemption: his scars. Red Dead Redemption 2 answer the inquiry of how John Marston acquired his notable facial markings, and the answer is extremely (and intentionally) underwhelming.


Related: The difficulty With Red Dead Redemption 2

The expose of john Marston"s scars arrives in the opening hours of Red Dead Redemption 2. One of the very very first story objectives of the video game has Arthur trying to find John top top a snowy mountain because he’d been missing for days. Arthur sets turn off with Javier Escuella, a minor antagonist from the an initial game, to find their lacking gang member. Together it turns out, he"s cowering on the height of a mountain, bloody, beaten, and with a face full of deep facial cuts since a few wolves clawed him. John Marston gained his iconic facial scars due to the fact that he couldn’t resolve a trio that wolves. Considering whatever the character does in Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2, that particular incident is absurd.



Red Dead Redemption 2 is smart and also self-aware sufficient to poke fun at this lame explanation. Havier Esceulla even comments to man that they have to come up with a far better story for the scars. Practically dying indigenous a handful of half-starved wolves out in the center of nowhere doesn’t specifically fit the entirety outlaw, cowboy personality. However, it"s not just the scar story one of two people that provides John look at bad. While John certainly has his moment throughout the campaign, he"s a bit of a screw-up, overall. He"s not as feeble as Uncle ( due to the fact that no one is as miserable together Uncle), but he"s not the camp"s golden boy either. The scar occurrence sets a criterion for a long story where John is shown over and also over in a bad light. He"s to be a devastating father to young Jack, simple captive, and the target of number of jokes.


It"s a little disappointing to see Red Dead Redemption 2 take it away some of the mystique and also majesty from John Marston. However dragging the original Red Dead Redemption hero through the dirt ends up adding much more to his character than it take away away. It"s essential to psychic that, while football player learned to appreciate and also admire man in Red Dead Redemption, the various other characters, particularly former members the Dutch"s gang, didn"t treat that the exact same way. Whether john is searching Bill Williamson, haver Esceulla, or even Duch himself in Red Dead Redemption, every one of them reacted to John roughly the very same way: disdainfully. During Red Dead Redemption, that was easy to attribute these reaction to the truth that man was working through the law against his previous family. Red Dead Redemption 2 paints a different picture.

See more: Naoh + Hcl Naoh Nacl H2O Type Of Reaction, What Type Of Reaction Is Naoh Hcl Nacl H2O


Arthur and also Javier don"t act together John"s run-in v the wolves and also its therefore scars space the first time John has screwed up. It absolutely isn"t John"s critical mistake throughout Red Dead Redemption 2"s campaign either. The fact is that no matter exactly how charming and also charismatic as john Marston appeared in the very first Red Dead Redemption in the boundaries of Dutch"s gang, he was the criminal equivalent of the annoying small brother constantly getting into trouble. Red Dead Redemption 2 go make man look prefer a little bit dimwitted - starting with his scars - but it"s in ~ the expense of putting the story the the original game in a whole brand-new and illuminating context.