In this write-up we will certainly discuss about Historical Cost bookkeeping (HCA):- 1. An interpretation of historic Cost accountancy 2. Benefits of historical Cost accounting 3. Limitations.

Meaning that Historical price Accounting:

Historical Cost bookkeeping (HCA), also known as traditional accounting, record transactions showing up in both the balance sheet and the profit and also loss account in monetary amounts which reflect their historic costs, i.e., prices that are usually the result of arm’s length transactions.

You are watching: Historical cost accounting advantages and disadvantages

The historical cost principle needs that audit records be kept at initial transaction prices and also that these values be retained throughout the accounting process to serve as the basis for values in the jae won statements. HCA is based upon the realisation rule which calls for the recognition of revenue as soon as it has actually been realised.


The realisation rule has critical implication affecting both the profit and also loss account and the balance sheet. The principle needs that only realised revenues be contained in the earnings statement. In the balance sheet, the realisation principle calls for adherence come the historical price of the assets till the legacy is sold, despite any changes in the value of the legacy (resources) hosted by a service enterprise.

Benefits of Historical price Accounting:

Arguments which are advanced in favour the HCA are detailed as follows:

1. Audit data under HCA are typically considered cost-free from bias, separately verifiable, and hence an ext reliable through the investing public, and also other outside users. Gaue won statements can conveniently be showed with the assist of pertinent documentary and also other evidence. Due to the fact that of the verifiability feature, accounting profession has an ext preference for traditional accounting

2. Historical accounting reduces come a minimum the degree to i m sorry the accounts may be influenced by the an individual judgements the those that prepare them. Being based upon actual transactions, it provides data that are less disputable than are uncovered in alternative bookkeeping systems.


3. It has been generally uncovered that users, internal and external, have actually preferences because that HCA and also financial statements prepared under it. Follow to Mautz, “if those that make management and investment decisions had not discovered financial reports based on historical cost advantageous over the years, transforms in accountancy would long due to the fact that have to be made”.

Ijiri, a solid supporter that HCA, says that HCA has actually played a far-reaching role in the past and will continue to be necessary in financial report in the future. Berkin favours historic cost since of its capacity to existing actual events without arbitrarily adjustments by management. According to him, if corporate earnings was arbitrarily readjusted to show the influence of inflation, labour would it is in in an untenable bargaining position.

4. Historical accountancy is also defended ~ above the ground the it is just the legally recognised bookkeeping system embraced as a basis for taxation, dividend declaration, specifying legal capital, etc.

5. Historical cost valuation is, among all valuation methods at this time proposed, the method that is least costly to culture considering the social expenses of recording, reporting, auditing and settling disputes.

Limitations the Historical price Accounting:


In an economic environment, where prices are constantly rising, as has actually been the case in most countries of the world, HCA ill from some limitations.

The drawbacks of HCA are noted as follows:

1. In times of inflation, the worth of money decreases and, therefore, the financial unit (e.g., rupee in India) i m sorry is used as a traditional of measurement walk not have a consistent value and shrinks in value as the prices rise.

The HCA ignores this decrease in the worth of rupee and also keeps including transactions acquired at different dates with rupees of differing purchasing power. Thus, in historic accounts, the monetary unit (e.g., rupee in India) supplied to measure incomes and expenditures, assets and liabilities, has a mixture that values relying on the date at which every item to be originally carried into the accounts.


The HCA is based on the assumption of stable monetary unit which assumes that:

(i) there is no inflation, or

(ii) The rate of inflation can be ignored.

This assumption does not prove true throughout inflation because of the readjust in basic purchasing strength of the monetary unit. This create serious problems in measuring and also communicating results of a service enterprise.


2. Secondly, HCA go not match current earnings with the current expenses of operations. Profits are measure in inflated (current) rupees whereas production expenses are a mix of current and historical costs.

Some costs are measure in very old rupees (e.g., depreciation), various other tend to be in more recent rupees (e.g., inventories), when still rather reflect existing rupees (e.g., wages, salary, selling costs and similar current operation expenses).

In general, whenever there is a time lag in between acquisition and utilisation, historical price may fine differ substantially from existing cost. Accordingly, HCA has tendency to report ‘inflated’ or “inventory’ profits and lower costs of consuming stocks and also fixed assets throughout a duration of raising prices.

‘Overstated’ profits come to be harmful in the complying with respects:


(a) Over-distribution of dividends.

(b) settlement of wage cases on terms which companies can not afford.

(c) too much taxation ~ above the corporate ar in general and also inequitable circulation of taxes burden between companies.

(d) Under-pricing of sales.


(e) investors being misled regarding the power of companies.

3. The ‘inflated’ earnings resulting under HCA are not the actual profits yet exaggerated and illusory. This reasons the depreciation allowance to end up being inadequate to replace fixed assets and also finance growth and expansion.

In periods of inflation, therefore, inflated profits result in substantial fall in the operation capital and in turn, in the operating ability of a business enterprise. This is a major problem and also is ideal illustrated by two examples.

Example 1: instead of of Inventory:

A company buys 20,000 items yearly on January 1 and sells them all by the finish of the year. In 2007 the price was Rs. 5 each, yet the caterer announces that on January 1, 2008 the price will be enhanced to Rs. 6. Throughout 2007 the item were sold at Rs.6 each and the agency had other costs of Rs. 10,000.

Under HCA, the profit and also loss account will appear as follows:

When the agency decides come buy new inventory to replace that i m sorry it has actually sold, that will require Rs. 1,20,000 (Rs. 6 X 20,000), but its cash resources amount to just Rs. 1,10,000 (sale proceeds Rs. 1,20,000 less expenses Rs. 10,000).

Thus, regardless of making a profit it is not in a place to preserve its operating ability without borrowing or raising more capital. Prefer this, change may take place in the price of the other inventories also. The longer the delay between goods being acquired and their being sold, the much more serious the situation is most likely to be.

Example 2: replacement of fixed Asset:

On January 1, 2007, a firm buys a device for Rs. 1,00,000 which it expects to critical for 5 years and have no scrap value. It has actually no various other assets or liabilities and distributes every one of its revenues to its shareholders. Its profits before providing because that depreciation is meant to be Rs. 30,000 per year. Tax is to be ignored.

The profit and also loss account the the certain for annually will be together follows:

The cash created by the service each year amounts to Rs. 30,000 represented by the trading profit; the depreciation charge merely amounting to an audit charge in stimulate to spread out the cost of using the an equipment over its meant life.

After 5 years, the firm will have produced Rs. 1,50,000 and distributed Rs. 50,000, leave a balance that Rs. 1,00,000 representing the original capital, which may be went back to the owners, or reinvested. However, if there have actually been significant increase in prices in the meantime, the firm will find that it has actually insufficient funds to replace the equipment, which has now got to the end of its financial life.

As with inventories, that is probable the a certain will change fixed assets on a regular basis, and also that the funds kept by virtue the depreciation will certainly not be used for straight replacement of the exact same machine.

However, the overall influence of the increase in the prices will be the same. By charging depreciation ~ above the historical cost, quite than top top the current expense of spend the assets, the accounts will certainly fail to show the true price of maintaining the operating volume of the business.

In a organization where the rate of inflation is quicker than the rate of profit growth, over there is without doubt an erosion in the complete operating riches and capability of the business. Funding intensive sectors such as steel, aluminum and also engineering are hard hit since of enhanced replacement costs and intense competition indigenous producers with more contemporary facilities.

Therefore throughout inflation, additional funds are essential to finance work (e.g., inventories, plant and also equipment, functioning capital, various other assets) in order to assistance a provided physical volume the production and sales. The level that these additional funds (investment) is likely to increase as a result of climbing prices, but this will certainly not be measured through the quantity of distributable profits reported by historical cost accounts.

4. Inflation causes many various other problems and dislocations, such together the following, which are not taken into consideration in HCA. The an outcome is that historical cost figures come to be of less and also less significance and also the value of accounts because that decision-making is severely restricted.

(i) cultivation uncertainty about magnitude that future costs and price changes for materials, labour and also capital equipment impair the company’s capability to finance itself internally since corporate income-taxes are based upon stated nominal revenues rather than genuine profits.

This has led come the corporate ar to depend mostly on exterior funds rather than on preserved earnings. Consequently, the expense of borrowings, i.e., the price of supposed return has increased as well as higher debt same ratios in the that company sector. Similarly, equity expenses tend to rise as debt price increase since equity shareholders also require a higher return in see of the increased risks and the decreased purchasing power resulted in by inflation.

(ii) organization responds by requiring greater returns on new capital projects than in lower inflationary periods. This commonly requires far-ranging increases in offering prices, which might be an overwhelming to impose because of vain or price controls.

(iii) throughout high inflationary periods, the economic instance becomes uncertain for usual man and businessman. Businessmen attach much more importance come the threats in new investments. Jobs expected to provide marginal return are offered up and also thus new productive tasks are curtailed.

This leader to a loss in as whole investments and also productive activity throughout the economy, bring about curtailed growth, fewer new jobs; boosted unemployment etc. Increased productivity and output are necessary to offset the decline in the value of the currency and also in basic standard the living.

(iv) over there is no distinction in the historical cost accounts between real and also fictitious growth. A rising number for sales over a period of time could be checked out to indicate a development in sales, yet the truth may it is in different.

In bespeak to determine the really position, the is vital to know how individual product price have adjusted over the period. The same difficulty arises in relationship to the trend in profits, however in this instance the position is further facility by obstacles in measure the profit number itself.

5. HCA is defended on the floor of its assumed objectivity. Objectivity is claimed since historical expense numbers are acquired from actual transactions that have been gone into into by the enterprise itself quite than (sometimes) native transactions that space being entered into by rather in the market-place.

The objectivity that is declared is largely unfounded due to the fact that of the visibility of alternative, generally embraced methods for computing depreciation, list valuation and comparable such items. As a result, over there is a severe credibility space in jae won reporting. Further, it is likewise argued that there is no definitive source of the accepted principles.

Chambers observes:

“This whole range of resources (of bookkeeping principles) is therefore open-minded that it is no exaggeration to say that nearly anything can be a ‘generally welcomed principle’—the access of alternative rules renders it possible for carriers to choose sets of rule which ‘on the whole’ grossly misrepresent income.”

6. Return historical expense generally to represent ‘current market value’ at the time of transaction, however, together time passes, the cost (value) the non-monetary item in the balance sheets tends to relocate further and also further from their current value due specifically to changes in the worth of money (inflation).

This phenomenon (under valuation the assets) makes the historical cost balance paper of minimal significance to interested external parties such as investors and also creditors, who may well be much more concerned around the current value the the economic resources owned by an enterprise than about the original expense of this resources.

Historical cost-based balance sheet does not truly stand for the resources held by an enterprise at the balance paper date, because that the worths at which castle are carried do not relate to the date yet to the day on i beg your pardon they were acquired.

HCA, thus, is compelled to exclude extremely relevant information around changes in the worth of resources that may have actually supervened in between their acquisition and also use or in between their acquisition and also the accounting date if they space still climate held. HCA is appropriate only if prices, in fact, do not change between the date that sources are acquired and the date they are provided or the accounting date, if that comes first.

7. Due to the fact that historical accountancy is based on realisation principles, benefit can conveniently be manipulated. By speeding up or retarding the time of the realisation that gains, profits can be increased or decreased. Management’s capacity to manage what earnings are report is well-known as ‘income smoothing’. Income smoothing is feasible under other bookkeeping approaches also. Yet with the acknowledgment of all gains accruing in a duration rather than gains realised in the period, the scope for earnings smoothing is much diminished (in other approaches) than that that HCA.

See more: Where To Get Rock Climb In Pokemon Diamond ? How Do I Get Hm Rock Climb

To conclude, the HCA has several drawbacks, which arise mainly from two of its basic principles: stable financial unit and also realisation principle. Additionally, there are problems that arise due to the fact that of number of acceptable, alternative audit methods, causing a multitude of possibilities because that presenting the very same transactions.

Solomons sums increase the case versus HCA in the complying with words:

“The details it (HCA) provides around the financial place of an enterprise is not pertinent to the situation of the companies at the accounting date. The information it provides around income does not faithfully represent ‘better offness’, and also what it discloses about financial position does not faithfully represent the place as it exist at the audit date. HCA outcomes in invalid and misleading comparisons. Insofar as it is riddled with arbitrary allocations, that numbers room incapable the being verified by recommendation to events and also conditions exterior the enterprise. In sum, its results are woefully doing not have in the qualitative qualities (relevance, reliability, representational faithfulness, neutrality, comparability, materiality, conservatism) that (are) seen to it is in the criteria by which audit information should be judged.”